The Denver Broncos picked Tim Tebow in the first round -- at #25 -- well ahead of where almost every observer expected him to be.
On ESPN, Tom Jackson (a former Bronco himself) was literally speechless -- staring blankly into the camera in the moments after the pick was announced. Even ten minutes later (when he had presumably found his voice), Jackson was saying "it's a question whether he will ever play at all."
Mel Kiper Jr. blasted the pick on a talent basis, saying in effect, that even though he may be a great kid, the skill level is not high enough, and his (flawed) throwing motion will mean an unsuccessful NFL career.
Whether Tebow can be a Pro Bowl quarterback in the NFL is an open question. But it's pretty safe bet that Tebow will never be in an Associated Press story that contains the words: "Member of the Denver Broncos arrested early Sunday morning..."
Here's what Denver gets: a good all-around athlete (who, by the way, dominated the best football conference in the country in college), who is now playing with a chip on his shoulder and something to prove to every scout, GM, and fan who doubted him. There are worse combinations.
And there is this Inconvenient Truth: drafting a QB in the first round is clearly a crap-shoot. And if you don't believe that, here are the names of a few of the QBs selected in just the top three picks in the first round in the last dozen years:
Tim Couch
JaMarcus Russell
Ryan Leaf
Akili Smith
Joey Harrington
Ummm....oh, and the jury is still out on Vince Young, who was also a "top 3".
Could Tebow be a bust a #24?
Undoubtedly.
But will he be a worse choice than Leaf (#3 overall) or Russell (#1 overall) or the others in the List of Shame?
No.
The "best and the brightest" in the NFL came up with those choices. Generally, the experts (like Kiper) looooooooooved those picks when they were made. And all of them were busts that handicapped their respective franchises for years, if not close to a decade.
Which brings us to our point for all the so-called experts (which, ironically, involves another professional sports franchise):
If every instinct you have is wrong, then the opposite would have to be right.
1 comment:
Great post. Did you happen to notice how Steve Young reacted to the pick during the broadcast?
He seemed very angry as he constantly interrupted the other 'talking heads' and repeated his belief that the Tebow pick and Marshall trade will cost McDaniels his job.
Post a Comment